Abrogation simply and succinctly explained

http://natashajsmith.wordpress.com/2012/06/26/please-god-please-make-it-stop

Othmane commented on “Please God. Please make it stop.”.

in response to Anudeep:

For those amongst us , with all respect to their beliefs ( including Ms. Smith ) who think that this behavior has no relation whatsoever with certain dominant community beliefs and the way it was treated in its aftermath by local institutions with reference to behavior towards “different” people, be they are amongst them or […]

You’re posting a video which seems ( according to the comments on Youtube ) to be some kind of propaganda against Islam. I’m sorry for Neeha ( as well as Natasha ). But you must know that these people are EXTREMISTS, do you think that all the Pakistani condone these acts and that ” raping children is an Islamic tradition ” (cf the video on Youtube ). Extremists as well as the polity ( in Pakistan and Afghanistan for instance) speeches meet their goals thanks to that kind of thinking. The Western’s ” look they are barbarians ” is a fuel to the ” look they hate us”. If you study the nascency of extremism in Islam, you’ll see Islamic Ideology is born when Arab Countries started what they called “Annahda” (Renaissance) in the late eighteenth early nineteenth. And has made the West his enemy because its only relation to it was through colonization so it was born to counteract colonization, certainly it has gone too far.We must also see that the “Western democracy” has been and continues to do when you see that in France for instance during the elections Nicolas Sarkozy insisted on the ” difference” between real French and French Muslims which lends credibility to the hate speech of extremists. I insist again, I do not condone this kind of practice ( also in religion a Muslim doesn’t have the right to force anybody to embrace Islam ). It’s really annoying to watch videos manipulated in this way, I’m sure a man can do the same documentary about evangelization in Africa or Muslims’ persecution in China and talk bad about Protestantism and Buddhism. But It is shameful, because instead of solving problems as the video may suggest, using it as it was on Youtube, it deepens it. Thanks for helping extremists, And note that the first victims of extremism are Muslims themselves

Othmane commented on “Please God. Please make it stop.”.

in response to Othmane:

You’re posting a video which seems ( according to the comments on Youtube ) to be some kind of propaganda against Islam. I’m sorry for Neeha ( as well as Natasha ). But you must know that these people are EXTREMISTS, do you think that all the Pakistani condone these acts and that ” raping […]

Absolutely not you can’t force anybody to embrace Islam. ‘no compulsion in religion’ (Qur’an: 2:256) Convincing maybe be, but it is up to the person ( who obviously is not Muslim) to choose.

Anudeep commented on “Please God. Please make it stop.”.

in response to Othmane:

You’re posting a video which seems ( according to the comments on Youtube ) to be some kind of propaganda against Islam. I’m sorry for Neeha ( as well as Natasha ). But you must know that these people are EXTREMISTS, do you think that all the Pakistani condone these acts and that ” raping […]

I doubt this belief of yours ” also in religion a Muslim doesn’t have the right to force anybody to embrace Islam” It is because of 2 reasons. 1. That the holy book tells to ignore all old verses for all new verses where ever there is a conflict of beliefs. 2. That to make the belief propagated by holy book on all world and all world governance (sharia ) had been told to be prime objective for anyone who wants to qualify as “true believer”. Please correct me if i am wrong ?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s